Title
Shared values/conflicting logics: working around e-government systems
Abstract
In this paper, we describe results from fieldwork conducted at a social services site where the workers evaluate citizens' applications for food and medical assistance submitted via an e-government system. These results suggest value tensions that result - not from different stakeholders with different values - but from differences among how stakeholders enact the same shared value in practice. In the remainder of this paper, we unpack the distinct and conflicting interpretations or logics of three shared values - efficiency, access, and education. In particular, we analyze what happens when social services workers have ideas about what it means to expand access, increase efficiency, and educate the public that conflict with the logics embedded in the e-government system. By distinguishing between overarching values and specific logics, we provide an analytic framework for exploring value tensions as values are enacted in practice.
Year
DOI
Venue
2014
10.1145/2556288.2556971
CHI
Keywords
Field
DocType
analytic framework,e-government system,conflicting logic,shared value,increase efficiency,social services worker,conflicting interpretation,different stakeholders,different value,value tension,social services site,social services,values,e government
E-Government,Computer science,Knowledge management,Creating shared value,Social Welfare
Conference
Citations 
PageRank 
References 
15
0.74
18
Authors
4
Name
Order
Citations
PageRank
Amy Voida167950.32
Lynn Dombrowski2546.41
Gillian Hayes31852155.64
Melissa Mazmanian423618.71